Property tax problems don’t always arise because someone has deliberately failed to declare income. Sometimes they begin with a misunderstanding of the tax rules and continue unnoticed for several years.
That was the position for a married couple who approached ATS Accountants about a jointly owned residential rental property.
The issue
The couple had owned and let a residential property for several years, with the rental income shared equally between them.
Although rent was being received, the rental profits hadn’t been fully reported to HMRC. A key factor was a misunderstanding about mortgage payments. The clients believed that capital repayments on their mortgage could be deducted when calculating taxable profit and, as a result, didn’t think the property was generating taxable profits.
By the time the position was reviewed, five historic tax years needed to be addressed. Rather than leaving the issue unresolved, we advised the clients to correct their tax affairs voluntarily.
Reconstructing five years of rental accounts
Before any disclosure could be made, we needed to establish the correct tax position. ATS Accountants reconstructed the rental income and expenditure for each of the five tax years, reviewing the available records and analysing items such as:
- rental income received
- mortgage costs
- insurance
- council tax where relevant
- professional costs
- repairs and replacement expenditure
- other property expenses.
Because the property was jointly owned, we also calculated each spouse’s share of the rental profits and the tax due on it.
The work showed why the amount paid towards a mortgage isn’t necessarily the amount that can be deducted when calculating taxable rental profit. Repaying the mortgage capital itself is not a deductible rental expense.
Using HMRC’s Let Property Campaign
Having established the historic position, we advised the clients to make voluntary disclosures through HMRC’s Let Property Campaign, which gives individual landlords with previously undeclared residential property income a route to bring their tax affairs up to date.
Separate disclosures were needed for each spouse, because each had their own tax liability on their share of the jointly owned property.
ATS Accountants:
- reconstructed five years of rental income and expenditure
- calculated the rental profits attributable to each individual
- calculated the resulting income tax
- considered the interest and penalties that applied
- prepared the Digital Disclosure Service submissions
- prepared the accompanying formal offers to HMRC.
The clients came forward voluntarily, rather than waiting for HMRC to identify the undeclared rental income.
The outcome
Through the disclosure process, the clients brought five years of historic rental income into the tax system and quantified their outstanding liabilities. Across the two disclosures, approximately £6,700 was payable, made up of historic income tax, interest and penalties.
The matter didn’t end as soon as the disclosures were submitted, though. An HMRC administrative issue later led to one of the clients receiving requests for historic Self Assessment returns, and penalty notices, for periods already dealt with through the disclosure. ATS Accountants helped challenge this and explained to HMRC that those years had already been included in the Let Property Campaign disclosure.
Making the initial disclosure is only part of resolving historic tax affairs. Keeping the calculations, submission records and correspondence can matter just as much if questions come up later.
What can landlords learn from this case?
Don’t assume cash flow equals taxable profit
A property can produce little surplus cash after mortgage payments while still generating a taxable rental profit. Mortgage capital repayments aren’t deductible simply because money has left the landlord’s bank account.
Historic problems can be corrected
Discovering that rental income should have been declared doesn’t mean the problem should be ignored. HMRC has established procedures for landlords to correct previously undeclared residential property income.
Voluntary disclosure can matter
How and when previously undeclared income is disclosed can affect HMRC’s approach to penalties. Landlords who identify historic errors should consider taking advice and dealing with the position before HMRC contacts them.
Good records make a difference
Where several years are involved, reconstructing rental income and allowable expenditure properly is essential. Missing expenses can mean too much tax is calculated, while claiming costs that aren’t deductible can understate the liability.
Joint ownership still creates individual tax responsibilities
Where a property is owned jointly, each owner needs to consider their own reporting obligations and tax position. Correcting one owner’s affairs doesn’t necessarily correct the other’s.
earlier case study, “When an HMRC Tax Problem Is About More Than the Numbers” If you’re dealing with historic property tax issues and an HMRC assessment rather than a voluntary disclosure, our earlier case study shows how we approached that situation.
Do you have undeclared rental income?
HMRC’s Let Property Campaign remains available for individual landlords who need to disclose previously undeclared income from residential property.
If you have rental income that hasn’t been declared, or you’re unsure whether historic rental income was reported correctly, it may be better to review the position before HMRC contacts you.
ATS Accountants can help you:
- establish which tax years need to be reviewed
- reconstruct historic rental income and expenses
- calculate the rental profits that should have been declared
- calculate the potential tax, interest and penalties
- notify HMRC of your intention to make a disclosure
- prepare and submit the Let Property Campaign disclosure
- calculate and explain the amount payable
- deal with later HMRC correspondence about the disclosure.
Once HMRC acknowledges your notification of an intention to disclose under the Let Property Campaign, you generally have 90 days to calculate the liability, make the disclosure and arrange payment.
Need to disclose historic rental income?
Contact ATS Accountants for a confidential initial discussion about your rental tax position and whether HMRC’s Let Property Campaign is right for your circumstances. You can also read more about our HMRC investigations support.